HACKER Q&A
📣 hubraumhugo

What's your experience with Cursor and Sonnet 3.5 for coding?


Just came across this Kaparthy tweet:

  Programming is changing so fast... I'm trying VS Code Cursor + Sonnet 3.5 instead of GitHub Copilot again and I think it's now a net win. Just empirically, over the last few days most of my "programming" is now writing English (prompting and then reviewing and editing the generated diffs), and doing a bit of "half-coding" where you write the first chunk of the code you'd like, maybe comment it a bit so the LLM knows what the plan is, and then tab tab tab through completions. Sometimes you get a 100-line diff to your code that nails it, which could have taken 10+ minutes before.

  I still don't think I got sufficiently used to all the features. It's a bit like learning to code all over again but I basically can't imagine going back to "unassisted" coding at this point, which was the only possibility just ~3 years ago.
[0] https://x.com/karpathy/status/1827143768459637073

I wanted to get some broader feedback before setting everything up. What’s your experience with this stack?


  👤 fallinditch Accepted Answer ✓
I'm in the same boat, about to get stuck in to Cursor. But I'm wondering if it might be better to go with a VS Code extension like Continue.

With Continue you can use your own local copy of an LLM, and also query LLM API endpoints, so therefore better for a pay as you go solution and cheaper if you are a heavy user. Also you can carry on using VS Code as your editor of course.

This is my understanding of the trade offs. I assume that Cursor has better functionality and is better at coding for it to be a serious option compared with the VSCode extensions. I'm going to try out both and see what I like best.


👤 dheerkt
Just set it up 2 days ago. I fully agree with his take. Cursor does a lot to reduce the headache of copy pasting results from ChatGPT/Claude.

Makes coding with AI much faster and less of a chore. You still need to know what you're doing as the models are fantastic at boilerplate but often get things wrong. But it's significantly sped up iteration for me, and hence translates to more fun.


👤 cloudking
What specific features make Cursor better than GitHub Copilot?

👤 elashri
Did anyone have similar experience with Cody comparing cody with cursor? Most of the metrics does not correlate much with everyday programming tasks.

Excluding sourcegrah employees who usually comment on these comparisons comments.


👤 Tiberium
I'm not using Cursor, but I'm still using Sonnet 3.5, although with https://aider.chat/ which is basically a TUI program to make the LLM a "pair programmer" - it can replace chunks of code, operate over multiple files, there's a repository map for it to check (for symbols), etc.

👤 hypersoar
I haven't tried Cursor, but I've been messing around with Aider (aider.chat) with interesting results. With it, you add files to its context and then describe the edits you want. It then writes a commit with (hopefully) those changes. You can use it with pretty much any model, though only close-to-SOTA models work well. I've had pretty good results with Deepseek Coder, which is tens of times cheaper than Claude.

👤 danielbln
I'm using Zed alongside its new LLM integration with Claude Sonnet 3.5 and I'm really really enjoying it. The workflow and the way you control what goes into the context feels very good and efficient and mimics the way I've been using LLMs before, just MUCH faster and convenient.

👤 sbrother
I just started using it a few days ago after hearing about it here.

So far, it feels transformational for my productivity. I've been using the ChatGPT and Claude webapps a few times a week for specific problems for a year, but this level of integration makes a big difference. Particularly for parts of the stack I'm not super experienced with -- I'm a backend/ML developer, but I was putting together a web UI with Tailwind for a personal project yesterday. I highlighted the ~20 lines of HTML for a menu bar, pressed Cmd+K and typed "can you make this take up a little less space on mobile?" and it adjusted the breakpoints and sizes of multiple elements perfectly. Pretty cool stuff.


👤 Kiro
Why was this nuked from the front page? I was really looking forward to this discussion.

👤 zackproser
Few months in with Cursor as my daily driver and I completely agree. I cannot unsee my productivity gains.

👤 e2e4
JetBrains has a pretty good integration with CoPilot, am wondering how cursor compares with it.

👤 bsshinple
It's been pretty good so far, settled as my main code editor. Prior to cursor I had to constantly provide context to GPT/Claude, now that's not necessary with cursor.

👤 pkilgore
It's nice. Look into the composer. I like it much better than inline completions.