HACKER Q&A
📣 websap

Why not auto replace paywall links with web archive links?


It would make reading and interacting with articles so much easier?


  👤 anigbrowl Accepted Answer ✓
I've suggested this too. At the least the archive link could just be added to the control row (immediately under the title) instead of being a crufty comment.

👤 pestatije
paywalls are there for a reason...the more you facilitate breaking them the more you resemble thepiratebay...and you dont want HN to end like that

👤 keikobadthebad
Don't want to be on the hook for contributory copyright infringement?

👤 joshxyz
or just have a bot that auto coomments the archive link. plausible deniability.

👤 brudgers
https://archive.ph/LnakG

On HN, linking to archive.org has traditionally been considered a user activity and some people have a bookmarklet for that purpose using this URL:

javascript:void(open('http://archive.today/?run=1&url='+encodeURIComponent(documen...))

If a submission doesn't matter enough for at least one user to do that, it probably doesn't matter enough to be on HN.

YMMV.

But this is Hacker news.


👤 paulcole
Why allow archive links to paywalled articles at all? Pay for the content or don’t read it.