HACKER Q&A
📣 EGreg

Given AI content generation, how will society know the truth?


I have increasingly seen deepfaked content where Both the text, the voices and the 3d models have been AI generated (eg with GPT-3, Audition, Stable Diffusion for video). We have been able to do this for a while.

Being in tech we have been aware of the progress of AI content generation for a while. AI can generate a ton of fake crap all day long and soon the actual human generated content will be a vanishingly tiny proportion. Most of the news and political speeches will be fake news, deepfaked war crime videos, and people will think they’re real.

For a while, “deepfake detection” will work until the deepfakes will become indistinguishable (up to a margin of error) from real stuff. At which point, we will only be able to rely on “official” sources, for anything. This is indeed a big issue, similar to how we rely on “official peer review” for science.


  👤 catchnear4321 Accepted Answer ✓
Image generation just makes the problem very visible… while making it harder to detect.

Bot armies have been influencing perception and attempting to shift direction for years. With words, often from anonymous strangers, on the internet.

“News” is a product, and your local news channel is often just the local distributor, not the creator. Sure, there are local stories, but the national ones are sometimes read word-for-word. “Official sources” starts sounding ominous, rather than comforting.

This might all eventually work out ok. People might have to step away from their screens, since the screens are known to lie rather convincingly.

And getting away from the screens? That will remind people they used to live, and dream, without the help of computers.

Humanity has been waving technology around recklessly since it learned to pick up a piece of wood or a rock. We’re crossing from the “Fuck Around” era to the “Find Out” one.


👤 Lockal
What does AI have to do with it? The same question can be asked about any information. For example, the news might say that a referendum was held in Donetsk, and with a turnout of 120%, 99% of people voted to join Australia. You don't need to deepfake it.

👤 sharemywin
it won't solve evetything but:

digital signatures will probably need to be in phones.