HACKER Q&A
📣 jbverschoor

How to reset your online bubble of 'interests'?


My feeds and suggestions on all platforms are sometimes fills with things that are current in that period. For example if you're moving, you basically only see home reno / decoration things.

Is there a way to 'reset' the interests profile on the platforms and start from scratch?


  👤 alexaholic Accepted Answer ✓
Facebook maintains a list of topics it thinks you are interested in and shows you ads based on that. You can see and manage it in the Ad Preferences section. See https://m.facebook.com/help/247395082112892

Google too has My Activity https://myactivity.google.com/ where you can manage your… activity on Google properties e.g. you can disable search history.

—-

FWIW I have Google history turned off, though I use DuckDuckGo 99% of the time.

Also I’ve reset my Facebook preferences once a couple of years ago. It was a very long process as there was no one button to clear them all… Anyway, I was hoping it would reset my Facebook experience entirely, but I wouldn’t say it did. I revisited the section some time later and found Facebook had built another list. A lot of seemingly random topics, but I suspect they’re weighted. I’m no longer logged in in any of my browsers, only the Facebook mobile app. Also I occasionally report ads for random reasons.


👤 pmontra
First of all prevent any bubble to form. Never sign in into to any service that can also work reasonably without signing in (Google, YouTube, etc.) Use Adblock in the browser, Blockada on phone and tablets, do not use FB and talk to friends IRL or on WhatsApp/Telegram. This basically makes sure that the only ads I'm seeing are on TV and billboards on the streets. Visit the HN front page to get some type of news and general news on 68k.news (a text only frontend to Google News, much faster and hopefully hidden from Google's algorithms.)

👤 eimrine
I use to do something similar last few weeks when I refused to read anything on my mother language except of few vloggers which are totally trusted for me. Now I am heavy user of HN and it never lets me feel that I am in a bubble. BTW I stopped using any IM years ago so refusing to consume everything except HN is not a very hard challenge for me.

I think all recommendations based on "personal interests" is evil because there are ultimately good things like Mathematics and ultimately bad ones like gossips. But if you will watch strictly 50% of Math content and 50% of gossip content, the recommendations usually offers kind of 90% of gossip and 10% of Math because gossip is way more popular among others and recommendation algorithms considers Math content as kind of boring. What makes the situation even worse that gossip content is way easier to consume for our brains. So we the people use to consume less content like Math if some high-quality gossip content is offered everywhere and maybe the only way to break this habit is to spend time on resources with totally no gossip content.


👤 mikewarot
If at all possible, I route around the advertiser funded algorithms, and do my own curation when I do use social media. For instance when I use Facebook, I do so through a web browser with adblock, and through the url ending in ?sk=h_chr which forces reverse chronological order.

If I notice one of my friends or subscriptions getting noisy with stuff that doesn't align with my desire to actually know more and enjoy life... that feed gets muted or dropped.

Curation is the key to all of this.


👤 stevewatson301
A more practical way I have gone around resetting things on Youtube is to search for stuff that I am genuinely interested in appearing in my feed, build a playlist off of that, and leave it playing. After a while, the algorithm "gets it" and starts showing the stuff I'd like to see.

I agree its more difficult on other platforms (FB etc.) as they require that you interact with the content. A similar idea that I haven't tried personally, might be to use a headless browser to navigate around and "doomscroll" posts relating to your area of interest.


👤 SllX
Without clarity on what you’re using, there’s not a lot anybody can offer you specifically.

Two examples though:

1. With YouTube I tell them for certain recommendations not to recommend me those videos or channels. Additionally I clear out any video from my history that’s not something I want to see more of (usually if I mis-clicked on a video of a political or social nature, but sometimes one-off lookups I initiated). YouTube treats a video removed from your history as one you never watched in your life and removes all instances of it from your history. You don’t need to be thorough about it either, removing some of a particular genre will generally shift its rating down enough that going forward it gradually disappears from your recommendations. This happens even if you don’t clear videos out, but just stop watching old types of videos and start watching new ones.

2. Create a new account. I do this once a year with Reddit. Gives me time to reconsider what it’s still good for and at this point that is very little, so that tradition may not be long for this world.


👤 system2
What feeds are you talking about? Where are you looking at?

👤 ivank
For Twitter: switch to 'Latest Tweets' or use the search "filter:follows include:nativeretweets"; unfollow everyone or make a new account, use Twitter search a lot to search for things you're interested in (I like to query for phrases that only domain experts would know about), follow intelligent-seeming people and check their following list; quickly unfollow or mute anyone who is bad at tweeting.

👤 infinityplus1
Don't login on social media. Use ublock origin and incognito mode everywhere. Add DNS based Ad Blockers on your every device.

👤 someweirdperson
Turn off all add-blockers, or at least make sure all servers of your platform(s) of choice are allow-listed.

Then search for and surf to topics of interest to seed the algorithms with new interests. No need to actually consume the content, just create hits on pages about what you consider relevant.

The algorithms will start to hear the new you.


👤 ajot
Do not log in, anywhere. Autodelete cookies for all sites (but a whitelist, there's something too inconvenient to log in every time. For me, it's whatsapp web) any time you close the browser window. Use NewPipe on your phone. Get an RSS reader and thus curate your own news sources.

👤 jcalvinowens
I've started using several different youtube accounts, each for watching specific categories of videos.

👤 hedora
I just don't log in; lock my browser to private mode (or use Firefox Focus, etc), and use a VPN.

Make sure your device ad identifiers are disabled, or clear them periodically.


👤 _trampeltier
Just allways use a browser in incognito mode only. On mobile is Firefox Focus a great choice with the "clear everything" button always on top.

👤 onemoresoop
Taking a break is the best reset in my opinion. Coming back to it with a different perspective can help asses the interests in a better light.

👤 pdntspa
New account / private browsing / adblock (sometimes)

👤 cykros
Log out, clear all cookies, get a new IP address (usually easy as unplugging your modem for an hour or so), and make new accounts. Better yet, don't make new accounts, and use platforms that don't require it -- or at least platforms whose accounts don't entail personalized advertising.

Or, you know, look into individual platforms data and privacy options. Google, for instance, allows you access to some settings via https://myaccount.google.com/data-and-privacy; presumably particularly in a post-GDPR world, most of the big platforms have something similar.

All depends how thorough you want to be. Reset a few advertising models, or basically join witsec.


👤 ThrowawayTestr
Delete your cookies? Make new accounts?

👤 keepquestioning
Discord.. discord.. discord

👤 FunnyBadger
Cold Turkey is one of the most effective ways. Close the old account and open an entirely new one if that's still on the table. Honestly all the problems that accrue with social media are net negative and are best avoided 100%. No point to reinflating the bubble again - because it WILL.

I went cold turkey on both Reddit and Quora and have zero plans to ever return to either. I proceeded to delete all posts I'd made in the last 10-20 years. Best decision ever! I could trivially recreate the content on different platforms if I ever really wanted to and it would be better the 2nd time.

I saw how these platforms treated me as akin to being bullied, having the bully demand I apologize for being beat up and then making money on my good will and contributions on top of that.

The obvious answer is to delete it all to deny them any benefit from the content and to stop the beatings and bullying. Life is too short for anything else.