HACKER Q&A
📣 super_throwaway

Proposal for an ActivityPub RSS Based News Aggregation Community


Over the past few years several open source decentralized platforms have emerged. Most modeled after existing sites and social networks, others being new concepts entirely. In this writing, I have taken concepts from rank oriented forums like Reddit and Hacker News, but incorporated them with RSS to make something free of biased algorithms. I believe this could give users not just a personal reader for themselves, but one that allows users to connect through comments and relational feeds. Ones that display feeds by what all users of an instance follow and feeds among multiple instances of this platform design.

How the main feed ranking works

Every user has their own personal subscription list of RSS feeds. Obviously by default they can view their own feeds like any old traditional reader. What makes this unique is there would be a local feed page. This would contain a list of most popularly subscribed feeds among users within that rss instance. There would also be another page for a global list of feeds across all instances which depends on the optional relationship between other instances. This being either uni/bi direction or no relationship at all. If instance A follows instance B, then A’s global list contains a rank of feeds by users of both A and B. Global isn’t strictly all instances because we want them to be federated and give the option to control any necessary resource overhead.

How users interact

A big problem with RSS’s lack of success is that the modern internet is far too complex for any single user to collect feeds on their own. We want users to click on other’s profiles to see what they follow, along with the option to follow whatever is on any type of list. On a local or global feed page, every item in that list has a comment section. This would be similar to HN and Reddit, but with downvoting and overall karma being optional per instance. Of course there could also be other feed ranked pages that make use of this karma similar to Reddit and HN.

Any feedback is appreciated.


  👤 tannhaeuser Accepted Answer ✓
Now what is it, RSS proper or ActivityPub? Asking because last time those alternative protocols (Atom, ActivityPub, etc) also contributed to killing what was left of RSS.

👤 jks
This seems to resemble how Google Reader used to work. I think you could share items to your contacts, or perhaps it was just "starring" items and your contacts would see what you had starred. You could write comments on items that your contacts would see, but there were never comment threads like on Facebook, or "liking" your friends' shares.