In this context, for me it is not a "very" early stage startup if I can read about it on AngelList or they have more than just a landing page.
There can be many signals for promising founders like their previous jobs or ventures or experience in that domain.
I believe it is easier for people who already know these founders as friends or colleagues but for others, not so much.
For example - Linear App in 2019 or Vercel in 2015 and such.