HACKER Q&A
📣 amichail

Why doesn't every home have an acceptable volume level for speech?


Talking too loudly would result in a computer voice telling you to lower your voice.

If you do not comply after several warnings, an alarm would sound that would make conversation impossible for a few minutes.


  👤 CM30 Accepted Answer ✓
Because most people wouldn't want that, and would find such a feature annoying as all hell?

If you want it for your own home it's likely not that difficult to set up on a technical level, but I suspect it might not go down too well with any visitors.


👤 EddieDante
> Talking too loudly would result in a computer voice telling you to lower your voice.

If a computer presumed to tell me how loudly to talk, I would have it recycled.

The computer is my servant, not my mistress.


👤 softwaredoug
I am that person for my kids :)

And honestly, it seems better that kids hear it from other people, rather than machines. Because kids need to learn to respect other people's boundaries in a shared space. A lot of parenting is actually you modeling asserting your own needs so they know they can do the same.


👤 brudgers
I'm not sure that the solution for loud talking is more loud talking.

I mean when our washing machine goes into its death spin cycle, we don't stop talking.

Instead we up the volume or move away and enjoy the benefits of the inverse square law at 6db per doubling of distance.

On the other hand, it sounds like a great jumping off point for a Youtube channel. https://www.youtube.com/c/simonegiertz


👤 marssaxman
If you were to actually develop such a system, instead of using an alarm, you might consider simply playing the speaker's voice back with a slight delay. It is a surprisingly disorienting effect - most people cannot continue talking through it.

👤 realPubkey
You should go to youtube and watch how planet fitness ensures people do not train to loud. Then you understand why noone wants that at home.

👤 sn0w_crash
Because most people don’t want a software or it’s developer telling them how to live their lives.

👤 VoodooJuJu
What the fuck?