This really got me thinking about this whole phenomenon. Of proliferation of "walled-gardens", of search engines like Chrome becoming less effective due to SEO optimization and thus users having to look elsewhere, whether that's Reddit, Quora, HN, etc.
Obviously, we all still occasionally browse the web, but it really doesn't compare to back in the days, at least for me.
What's happened to the web??? How much is because of shifts in technology, and how much is because of a cultural shift, of how we use the web, of the type of information we seek (eg preferring people-mediated information like Reddit/Quora/HN, rather than static information sources like a website dedicated to a topic)?
Maybe this isn't necessary bad thing? Or is it? If we could dream up a different search environment and different technologies surrounding the internet and the WWW, what would it be?
[0]: https://news.ycombinator.com/item?id=31111394#31114748
Inside:
My own websites, which I make for myself and friends.
HN
Nitter, Teddit
A little bit of mbasic and insta
Everything else generally gets the close-tab (Just "w" in my browser) and nothing of value is lost.
With human-human relationships, it's common wisdom to avoid assholes, inconsiderate people, profiteers, the inconsiderate, parasites, manipulators, those who take advantage of us, liars, those who violate our privacy or don't respect consent, and so on...
I think it makes a lot of sense to apply the same rules in my relationships with other types of entities as well.
I'm liberal with second chances, but the backoff is exponential ))
Some sort of "distributed comment section" that you bring along when you visit a site could bridge this gap, but I haven't seen anything event remotely ready.
I mean technically you can have a chat with your friends and share a link. But that doesn't really have this "live", "organic" feel of a public square.
In the beginning (Web 1.0), it was one of static websites. Web 2.0 made it interactive, allowing for user input such as comments etc., which laid the foundation for the more recent explosion of walled-gardens and web-apps.
While it's easy to celebrate the old and criticize the new, in the end nothing is intrinsically "good" or "bad". With the web being a container of possibilities, it means we're free to dream, design, and defend whatever it is that we want the web to be.
That's my philosophical take anyway.
It didn't used to be that way. Once upon a time, the idea that you'd expose your credit card or other personal details on the internet was inconceivable. With this change came the end of the fun Internet.
Like replacing captcha with a fee.
While people may think.. this is just an added expense.. remember you can also make money too!
I'm old enough to remember when that's the only mode there was!
now we have "feeds", infinite scrolling of content we never asked for, paywalls and cookie popups.
I feel like the solution would be complete backend/frontend separation. imagine reddit as being only a comments database, your user is an api key and the website is just one of many frontends displaying queries on that database. right now we have only one frontend pushing whatever "the algorithm" thinks is optimized. but maybe then we will have freedom.