HACKER Q&A
📣 mapsdkhsd

How do I shutdown a project my users love?


I am a college student at Carnegie Mellon. I built a utility-based social network for CMU students.

https://starterpack.live/

CMU has a yearly Carnival which was this weekend, so I chose to launch it then. In our first day, we penetrated about 50% of all undergrads, and we are getting good use. My idea is simple and seems effective.

Except I messed up and launched too quickly since the semester is already soon over, and launching next fall would've been oppurtune. This is not the right time to expand to other schools since summer is coming. I should've started with another market.

Further, I'm poor! I've had a horrible response from investors (can't beat incumbents, doesn't scale, solo-founder, part-time, have to find product market fit for each community, Reddit can just copy). I grew up sporadically homeless and my family is still financially troubled, so I will be working remotely at my internship and at my family restaurant until 11pm everyday this summer. It is so frustrating.

For the CMU starterpack, I am making a daily Wordle-like puzzle, updating the fence, moderating, and adding new features. However, even as more CMU students use it, I want to discontinue it as I realize this will be more prohibitive come summer than beneficial.

How do I gracefully shutdown so that I may revive the project next school year?


  👤 groffee Accepted Answer ✓
You don't.

A social network is a community, a home for people. If you kill it now then that's it, it's over, dead, finished, finito, you won't be able to revive it because you killed all your users trust.

Hand it over to your active users or keep it going, and forget about investing, just ask for donations from your users, that will keep you going and you'll get more than you thought possible, not everything needs to be FB/Reddit scale.


👤 rubyist5eva
I’m gonna go against the grain here and just say it - just give your users a date and turn it off on that date. You don’t owe them anything beyond that. If you don’t want to run it and can’t find someone who does, oh well. It’s your creation and your life. Take the experience and move on.

👤 h2odragon
Lay it out to your users straight up. If theres a level of funding that lets you keep running, you might consider a fundraiser; but "I have to shut down for a while and we'll come back next fall we hope" doesn't sound that bad. You don't seem to have an obligation to your users other than joy in the community, which is wonderful but life comes first.

👤 epc
Is it cost prohibitive to just let it run? Can you lock it down, and let it run? Otherwise I’d just pin a note saying you’ll shut it down (or suspend it) at the end of the semester.

👤 thatloststudent
I think it's best to maybe put a pinned post on the top explaining the situation and asking for donations. In that way, you're giving them some control.

👤 gus_massa
Perhaps you can add ads to the site to cover the cost.

👤 yuppie_scum
Patreon