HACKER Q&A
📣 farqws

Should all politicians be banned from Twitter?


Many people had the hope that politician's presence on Twitter would enable more direct contact with the citizens. However, all political sides mainly use Twitter to dumb down discourse, virtue signal and blast out propaganda.

I think it is time to return to the pre-Twitter days.


  👤 version_five Accepted Answer ✓
> all political sides mainly use Twitter to dumb down discourse, virtue signal and blast out propaganda.

That's what most people appear to use it for. Stop using twitter and join a social network or news source or whatever you want that meets your needs. Or form a closed twitter group that doesn't include politicians.

I think twitter in particular has destroyed modern discourse, but we're not going to ban our way out of this.


👤 retrac
Like with proposals to regulate "journalists", what exactly constitutes a politician? For example, I've run for public office before (city council) and I'm involved in a few politically active organizations. Am I a politician? If I am, was it still political advocacy when I talked about the idiotic redudant school built in my ward, as I was not campaigning then? (Just a thought experiment. In practice, Twitter should of course be scourged from the planet.)

👤 oblib
> all political sides mainly use Twitter to dumb down discourse

It's true that politicians and their followers have dumbed down discourse (and to a stunning degree) but ultimately it's the consumer of that discourse who needs to change and Twitter is not standing in the way of that.

I don't "tweet" or follow Twitter much at all but I think it's fair to say that on any given day there is a lot of very useful, helpful, and positive banter going on there.