HACKER Q&A
📣 rukshn

How do know if a problem is big enough?


How do you know if a problem is big enough to work on and whether it will have a good enough market?

I've conducted a small survey to identify a probable market for a problem before started building anything, and it turned out to have mixed results.

Like 55%-45% split.

How do you decide whether a problem is big enough solving?


  👤 muzani Accepted Answer ✓
Personally, I find surveys don't work. In tech, you want to be building products that are 10x better. e.g. half the price, 10x faster, but at half the quality. But a thing like this is just never going to be understandable in a survey.

Like if Uber wanted to launch, what kind of survey would they even put up? Hail a taxi, but it's someone's car and they'll treat you better than a professional? Also it'll be safer than a licensed, regulated taxi.

Gmail: Would you like 1 GB of email storage vs Microsoft's 5 MB? (and it's free, filters spam better, and has a better UI)

Steam: Would you like to buy games for an average 4 times cheaper, and download them fast, legally when you feel like it? The CDs won't scratch and you can own the games on any PC with internet access.

Instagram: Would you like a shareable photo album that is infinitely cheaper than Photobucket with unlimited storage? Oh, it makes you prettier too.

If you can ask questions in a survey, that don't make people suspicious, maybe you're not aiming high enough.


👤 MaknMoreGtnLess
While I am happy to go into TAM and related metrics, I am assuming this is your first successful startup.

In that case, don't worry about the market - infact, having just a few dozen paying customers who can be fit in 1 to max 3 personas but those that you understand very well, can reach well and get immediate feedback from is very important.

> I've conducted a small survey to identify a probable market for a problem before started building anything, and it turned out to have mixed results.

- How exactly did you conduct the small survey?

- What kind of questions did you ask?

- Did you use a form or conducted 1:1 interviews?

- How did you source the participants?

- What was the motivation of the participants?

> Like 55%-45% split

split of what?

Is your solution a whisper idea? Or can you share it?


👤 favourable
I build for the problem I have, not the problem I want.

👤 shavin47
Check this matrix out, it'll help you think about it https://www.getrevue.co/profile/mjwhansen/issues/analyzing-c...

👤 sheinsheish
Probably not what you are looking for but might be worth it

https://blog.appsumo.com/validating-your-business-idea/


👤 dusted
n / (m-c)

Where n is the number of instances of the problem, m is price the market will pay for solving an instance and c is the cost of solving it.


👤 hougan
It depends on different parameters.

👤 raleighm
What do you aim to achieve by tackling the problem?

👤 brudgers
Is the problem the size of a bicycle?