One day I decided to browse some of those emails for nostalgia reasons. The pattern of opening emails one after another must have triggered something, because I got locked out during browsing. It's been months and it still won't let me in - I know the password, I've resurrected old hardware, no luck. It's all quite frustrating.
Can one appeal? I haven't figured out how. The one last strategy I haven't tried yet is reaching out to a Google employee.