HACKER Q&A
📣 syspec

Hacker News, but for Finance?


HN is full of intelligent respectful discourse, with tons of insight gained by reading the comments.

Is there anything similar to HN, that covers finance topics (such as markets, etc)?


  👤 TheGrkIntrprtr Accepted Answer ✓
This might be what you’re looking for: https://www.valueinvestorsclub.com/

Famous investors such as Michael Burry were discovered there. You don’t have to participate, you can have a guest account with a delay on seeing new posts. There are some insightful comments that you can read as well.

Edit: you don’t have to create an account to view posts


👤 buwka
In regards to personal discussion: bogleheads. Otherwise same principal as HN that as a community grows large, especially in finance or other trendy topics, the quality of discussion drops.

👤 wesammikhail
There are plenty of places you can find high quality financial content/discussions. Some have already been listed in this commect section.

With that said, the problem we have is not one of curation which is what HN or Reddit does. The actual problem is the lack of strcture and searchability/discovery. Even on HN once something fades off of the front page, it is lost forever.

Here is an idea I have been considering for some time now: Imagine a website where you get to input a stock ticker symbol and you get back a timeline (literally a zoomable timeline) with all major events related to that ticker on that timeline. Each event has relevant links/documents attached to it. That way you categorize all the necessary information related to a company from its inception until today in one single place.

Even if you're talking about general finance and not stocks or investment grade assets. The problem is the same. We have an ocean of content all over the place but no structured way of search or discover what we seek to know more about. So imo finding creative ways to structure the content is the problem to solve for.


👤 reducesuffering
https://bogleheads.org/forum/index.php

Some very intelligent passive investors there. You can learn a lot about the details of different asset classes, optimal ETF choices and intricacies of them like securities lending, bond interest rates and duration, portfolio construction, market factor investing, research paper discussion on historical returns, reducing taxes, etc.

You won't learn stock picking.


👤 monkeyjoe
Not mentioned yet is http://elitetrader.com. There is a lot of crap but if you spend enough time to learn which posters are legit then you can really learn a lot. There is also like 20 years of history to look up in the forums if you are inclined.

👤 gradschool
I haven't followed this in a while, but the last time I checked it had lots of very knowledgeable smart people on it.

https://forum.wilmott.com/


👤 rwalk
I’ve found a lot of high-quality, quant finance blogs from this (curated) feed:

https://quantocracy.com/


👤 joshxyz
I think twitter threads are what you're looking for. Find smart people like SBF of Alameda/FTX, they do tweetstorms (threads of tweets) every once in a while.

👤 nathanasmith

👤 mooreds
The finance forums I have found all have pretty strong community viewpoints.

Places like bogleheads.com may be worth a look.


👤 gitgud235
TLDR: it does not exist.

I used to be quite interested in finance or 'quant-finance'. Besides from taking too many courses in analysis and 'applied' mathematics like stochastic processes, bayesian methods, SDE's, etc. I have searched through a-lot of shitty Reddit forums and bad YouTube channels.

They are all bad, and no-one is actually doing anything. Sometimes there is Kaggle-competition like this one [1] where people are actually doing something and not just implementing a naive Black-Scholes model in Python with toy data, but again, in my experience it all linear models that run in production.

Depending on where you live I think there is a much higher change connecting with other people with engaging in finance-clubs at your local university or maybe get an internship/job.

The only real value I have got out from searching/reading about (quant) finance is [2] A Man for All Markets: From Las Vegas to Wall Street, How I Beat the Dealer and the Market, but you can skip the 5 first chapters.

1: https://www.kaggle.com/c/optiver-realized-volatility-predict...

2: https://www.amazon.com/Man-All-Markets-Street-Dealer/dp/1400...


👤 ricardbejarano
Yes please, I thought of asking several times about something like you describe, but never got to do it.

👤 tricky
keep an eye out for quality forums, as well. I have been out of it for a long time, but on the quant side there was nuclearphynance.com and wilmott.com - I imagine there are less specialized forums with quality people out there somewhere.

👤 tamiral
r/wallstreetbets

👤 born_on_sega
zerohedge.com

👤 kryptonomist

👤 toomuchtodo
r/econmonitor

👤 GDC7
Nobody knows what the fuck they are talking about and everybody ranging from Warren Buffett to Jimmy Buffett are just winging it.

Finance is essentially psychology with 6 months weather forecasting slapped on top of it.

It's way easier to predict the fate of the Universe trillions of years from now than it is to predict where Microsoft stock will sit 4 months from now.


👤 badinsie
the only topic you need to follow right now is here - https://ns.reddit.com/r/Superstonk/