It's incredibly frustrating reading!
There have been many Mars rovers and orbiters. What, if anything, have they conclusively proven, beyond a shadow of a doubt? Why is it so apparently incredibly difficult to prove whether Mars has/has had water or not?
In case it's not obvious, I know nothing about astronomy, physics, geology, biology etc, so please don't be snarky. I just genuinely don't understand what's so difficult.
And there's truly very little data to be had and what there is "supports" different interpretations but doesn't exclude others. Similar to how Radio astronomers have all these lovely maps and reams of signals and they're still "making up" most of their inputs via interpolation and squinting at samples from alternate eyeballs.