Is it wrong to make money with a .org?
I have an ethical/consious product/service that is for-profit, but self funded. I think a .org would be nice for it, as it serves users well and ethically, but the service does generate income. Is this frowned upon today?
I would be more concerned with whether it is legal than whether it is ethical. I agree that being ethical is important, but as ethical issues go, this is pretty minor. Making the choice to never divorce your wife would be a much more important ethical decision.
'.org' never meant "non-commercial", it meant "not primarily commercial".. no one has, or had, problems with somegame.org making money even before they were charging for domain names and these questions were new.