HACKER Q&A
📣 easterncalculus

Is Your Spacebar Working on YouTube?


I noticed this earlier, and I'm not the only one, I've asked around and people have tried using it in the search bar on Firefox and it just doesn't work.


  👤 beiller Accepted Answer ✓
Space bar is hilarious for me on YouTube/Firefox. Some times it gets into a certain focus state (play button focussed?) and hitting space bar will briefly pause it, then resume playback. Hilarity ensues as I scramble, pausing a few times to realize the issue, and change the focus to something else by clicking the video canvas then press spacebar again for success.

👤 mtmail
Three users submitted that to HN in the last 15 minutes, seems to be tracked at https://bugzilla.mozilla.org/show_bug.cgi?id=1697551

👤 mmcclure
I noticed this this AM and assumed it was something around Firefox or otherwise specific to me. The situation for me was not being able to create a new playlist when saving a video because it would trigger all of the keyboard shortcuts while typing. It would mostly work...until you get to a letter like "f" and fullscreen blows away the modal.

This is a bit of a cautionary tale around the dangers of hijacking "normal" behavior: when a bug happens, you break really, really basic things.


👤 hexo
It is fascinating that people file this as bug to firefox bugzilla when it is clearly bug on youtube side

👤 alucardo
I use k instead of the space bar for a long time.

👤 benbristow
Nope, seems to be broken for me too. Screencast on my tweet below.

https://twitter.com/benbristowuk/status/1369710606257958918


👤 zoid_
Google are so clumsy accidentally leaving in these hard to find bugs throughout their products eh?

I guess the only solution is for us all to switch to Chrome, everything works fine that way.


👤 sidpatil
This isn't the first time I've encountered this bug before—I've seen it while using LinkedIn's messenger as well.

👤 recursive
No.

Version 86 on Windows.

Also space to toggle pausing during playback has worked only intermittently for some time. Always solid in Chrome. I think it depends what's focused, but never figured out the details.


👤 aequitas
Reading the headline I was afraid YouTube started disabling the Spacebar for play/pause because of some vague UX reason. But it's the other way around.

👤 AlphaGeekZulu
I can not enter space in the search widget on

- MacOS/Firefox - Ubuntu/Firefox

I can enter space in the search widget on

- Ubuntu/Chrome - Ubuntu/Brave - Ubuntu/Opera - Ubuntu/Vivaldi


👤 frankzander
Open the developer tools, disable the caching in the network tab and reload. at least here now the spacebar is working again.

👤 superfamicom
On macOS 10.15.7 (19H114):

- Chrome: Yes (89.0.4389.72 (Official Build) beta (x86_64))

- Safari: No (14.0.2 (15610.3.7.1.10, 15610))

- Firefox: No (86.0 (64-bit))


👤 exabrial
How about is your cursor working on Google search or was that "optimized"?

👤 ryanwhitney
Nope. Can’t use space in search.

Safari on Mac.


👤 pensatoio
Broken AF. Was about to restart my computer.

It’s hilarious that something so simple can break.


👤 rjsw
Broken, it did work yesterday and haven't updated Firefox.

👤 dathinab
Maybe, but I don't have the problem (Linux, FF, wayland).

👤 dhimes
No. But Alt 32 will give the space (Win 10 Firefox)

👤 tux3
No, it's broken! Firefox 87 beta on Debian

👤 HoverSausage
It's working for me. Firefox 78 on Debian

👤 matbilodeau
It works in the search bar

👤 johnchristopher
Firefox 86, Kubuntu 18.04.

It works.

Ah!


👤 kgwxd
Nope

👤 octocop
nope, doesnt work

👤 gioscarab
broken