HACKER Q&A
📣 herodoturtle

Why aren't we talking more about matrix?


Why aren't we talking more about matrix?


  👤 herodoturtle Accepted Answer ✓
Dear developer friends from afar, please hear my innocent pondering:

I wonder whether, upon the advent of quantum computing, hackers gaining access to Signal's databases will easily decrypt our private messages?

Or is it guaranteed that Signal's encryption algorithm will have evolved at a sufficient pace to remain effective?

Is it not in our best interest to more seriously consider decentralised platforms such as matrix?

But is the very same risk of hacking and decryption not also a weakness of matrix? Is the lack of security policing over its multiple independent nodes inevitable?

-

I hope you'll indulge me with your thoughts, because I've had little luck figuring out which solution is wisest - and I want to do what is best for our children's children.

To be honest, there's a part of me that just wants to ditch digital messaging altogether, and get back to the basics - old school fundamentals - as in, we're using the phone only to make plans to meet with people face to face so that we can chat in private, and we type out old-fashioned printed letters, whose hard-copy output is encrypted with our unique public keys - one for each different pen pal.

That would be pretty romantic, but things would take forever.

But could we emulate something similar if we each set up our own matrix servers at home?

As in, if we were to all run our own private messaging servers, and exchanged encrypted messages with each other using unique private and public key pairs, whose streamlined access allows us to easily maintain and continuously update these key pairs with all of our contacts - wouldn't that be the superior option?

I conclude that it's a trade-off between simplicity and independence. I am also ready to stand corrected on my interpretation of the nuances of this deeply impactful topic, and would value your thoughts and speculations of the future.


👤 rainmaking
I think we aren't talking more about Matrix because a severe form of "Not Invented Here" syndrome is rampant on the West Coast of the United States.