HACKER Q&A
📣 DrNuke

Why the negativity about all non-free products or services?


It is a number of weeks HNers have been going to fully fledged war (made of flagging or nitpicking and downplaying comments) against any non-free product or service that gets on the frontpage!? Why? How do these brigades think makers and doers have to sustain their startups? There is an underlying rage at global level that needs to be addressed, imho, because it is not healthy to innovators (people going against the tide, you know... not dark or gray masters only aiming at the booty). This is not a meta-thread bashing the community, it is an attempt to make both parties, creators and users, agree a new common ground for 2021 and beyond.


  👤 SubGenius Accepted Answer ✓
> HNers have been going to fully fledged war

That's not accurate though, is it? Unless you're exaggerating for effect.

I don't think most people on HN are against non-free products at all. I think they're against products that provide little value compared to their price.

There may also be some general exhaustion from so many products moving to a subscription model, instead of an old-fashioned one-off purchase. $9/month may not seem a lot, but it quickly adds up.


👤 sigmaprimus
I have not observed what You have, infact from my POV it seems the opposite of what You have described.

Sure there are zealots on both sides and they always tend to be the loudest voices in the room but over all, I find that premium products offering value and not just rebranding otherwise free products are met with positivity.

I think it's interesting how the same thing can appear so different, depending on who is looking.


👤 cracksmoka420
Free as in "freedom" or free as in "free beer"?

Non-free (as in freedom) software is not something that any self-respecting programmer would willfully associate with because it's inherently dirty. A proprietary license is (literally) a form of DRM. It's a feature that is hostile towards its users, especially those who are "makers" or "doers."