HACKER Q&A
📣 milkers

Why HN lets sharing content that is behind a paywall e.g. WSJ?


I frustrate when I clicked to a title or entry and when I go to the tab I see that I need to pay for a subscription to see the content. I think this creates a great struggle in an open community like HN.


  👤 bristleworm Accepted Answer ✓
True, although I wouldn't like prohibiting paywalls. Maybe displaying [Paywall] next to the title would be a solution?

👤 tomhoward
This topic gets questioned/debated weekly, including most times a paywalled article gets on the front page.

It is answered in the FAQ [1] and re-iterated frequently by dang.

Paywalled pages are OK if a bypass is available. If there is one, usually someone will post it in the comments.

If nobody has yet, you could try viewing the article in http://archive.is/ or https://outline.com/, and if it works, share the link here.

If no paywall bypass is available, the item should not be on HN, so you should flag it.

[1] https://news.ycombinator.com/newsfaq.html


👤 italiano
People w subscriptions should just copy and paste the articles in the comments

👤 LUmBULtERA
Because some valuable content may cost money to access. FWIW, at least many/most U.S. library systems let you access such paywalled content for free, so I recommend getting yourself a library card if you're in the U.S. :).

👤 gtirloni
Let me be the devil's advocate and ask: Why should paywalled content be penalized?

👤 busymom0
Don't have an answer for why but usually when I find a paywall, I paste the link on either archive.org or archive.is and find the article without paywall. archive.org often works better.