1. Put a bookmark list page on my website on a subdomain or embed it.
2. Access control and management with multiple members or family.
3. Detach myself from it anytime I want with a local offline app to browse them later on. (I hate subscriptions)
Bonus - open source, privacy oriented.
Things I did check out - pinboard, umark, pocket, evernote, notion etc.
Maybe my requirements are common or obscure so I also made a survey (plug) - https://forms.gle/WcgWKR95M5fgxsW97
I've also tried:
- Pinboard (favorite)
- Raindrop
Have a lot of bookmarks already and value to your time? You are better off going into Bookmark Manager on Firefox or Chrome/Chromium and organizing there.
I learned that the hard way - none of the bookmark places are good at bulk organizing tagging unfortunately! So if you're getting into a dedicated bookmark service, assume upfront time organizing what you have currently.
Unfortunately - why I ultimately burnt out is none of them - to my knowledge - sync back into chrome bookmarks so I get them in the bar. And they don't integrate / sync with my bookmarks in Chrome automatically. These services end up getting bolted on and treated as second class to the browser's bookmark manager. So they're not bookmarks anymore.